Piendle v. R.J. Reynolds

Trial 07/14/10 – 08/19/10

Case Number: 2008CA038777
Status: Concluded - Verdict
Industry: Tobacco
Practice Area: Tobacco, Products Liability, Toxic Torts, Negligence, Tort Law
Judge: Robin Rosenberg
Court: Palm Beach County Courthouse
Jurisdiction: 15th Judicial Circuit of Florida

Description

Engle-progeny tobacco jury trial.

Charles Piendle died of lung cancer at age 55, after 30 years of smoking. His widow Margaret established at trial that Charlie was addicted to smoking, and that his addiction caused his death from lung cancer, and thus she was entitled to recover damages as a class member in the Engle litigation.

The jury apportioned 45% fault to Mr. Piendle, and 27.5% each to R.J. Reynolds and Philip Morris. The jury awarded $4M in compensatory damages, and $270K in punitive damages.

For more information, visit the CVN Blog.

Sessions
Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.

August 19 - AM Session

Not in Session

August 19 - PM Session

Verdict - Damages

		Description
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:55	00:00:55	Reading of the Verdict
00:02:00	00:02:00	General Case Activities
00:04:15	00:04:15	End of Session

August 18 - AM Session

Closings - Damages

		Description	Attorney
00:00:03	00:00:03	General Case Activities
00:00:36	00:00:36	General Case Activities
00:07:38	00:07:38	Closing Statement	Barnhart, Gregory
00:48:36	00:48:36	Closing Statement	Biersteker, Peter
01:11:03	01:11:03	General Case Activities
01:13:44	01:13:44	Closing Statement	Biersteker, Peter
01:21:06	01:21:06	Break
01:49:48	01:49:48	Closing Statement	Kelly, Frank
02:23:23	02:23:23	General Case Activities
02:29:26	02:29:26	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:37:14	02:37:14	General Case Activities
02:38:23	02:38:23	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:40:08	02:40:08	General Case Activities
02:41:46	02:41:46	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:43:54	02:43:54	General Case Activities
02:44:10	02:44:10	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:45:03	02:45:03	General Case Activities
02:45:30	02:45:30	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:48:08	02:48:08	General Case Activities
02:48:45	02:48:45	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:51:30	02:51:30	General Case Activities
02:52:15	02:52:15	Closing Statement	Scarola, Jack
02:58:43	02:58:43	General Case Activities
03:00:38	03:00:38	End of Session

August 18 - PM Session

Not in Session

August 17 - AM Session

Defense Witness(es) - Damages

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:01	00:00:01	General Case Activities
00:00:19	00:00:19	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
00:24:51	00:24:51	General Case Activities
00:30:18	00:30:18	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
00:51:07	00:51:07	Break
01:19:21	01:19:21	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
02:09:21	02:09:21	End of Session

August 17 - PM Session

Defense Witness(es) - Damages

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:10	00:00:10	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
01:30:40	01:30:40	Break
01:53:02	01:53:02	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
02:20:20	02:20:20	General Case Activities
02:22:45	02:22:45	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
02:27:15	02:27:15	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
02:30:44	02:30:44	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Heimann, Robert	Transcript Reading
02:32:30	02:32:30	General Case Activities
02:34:55	02:34:55	General Case Activities
02:36:02	02:36:02	End of Session

August 16 - AM Session

Not in Session

August 16 - PM Session

Other

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:01	00:00:01	General Case Activities
00:01:21	00:01:21	General Case Activities
00:04:30	00:04:30	Opening Statement
00:12:16	00:12:16	Witness Direct Examination		Heimann, Robert	Video Recording
00:24:55	00:24:55	Witness Direct Examination		Heimann, Robert	Transcript Reading
00:28:45	00:28:45	General Case Activities
00:31:05	00:31:05	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Adams, Thomas	In Person
01:12:50	01:12:50	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Adams, Thomas	In Person
01:35:00	01:35:00	Break
02:03:58	02:03:58	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Adams, Thomas	In Person
02:13:30	02:13:30	General Case Activities
02:16:00	02:16:00	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Adams, Thomas	In Person
02:23:50	02:23:50	General Case Activities
02:28:15	02:28:15	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Adams, Thomas	In Person
02:30:48	02:30:48	General Case Activities
02:33:45	02:33:45	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Adams, Thomas	In Person
02:35:25	02:35:25	General Case Activities
02:39:45	02:39:45	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Adams, Thomas	In Person
02:49:02	02:49:02	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Adams, Thomas	In Person
02:54:45	02:54:45	General Case Activities
03:00:30	03:00:30	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Lupovich, Dr. Peter	In Person
03:25:00	03:25:00	End of Session

August 5 - PM Session

Other

		Description
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:01:42	00:01:42	Reading of the Verdict
00:08:00	00:08:00	General Case Activities
00:08:43	00:08:43	General Case Activities
00:09:40	00:09:40	General Case Activities
00:14:46	00:14:46	Break
00:16:38	00:16:38	General Case Activities
00:18:35	00:18:35	Break
01:00:10	01:00:10	General Case Activities
01:13:40	01:13:40	General Case Activities
01:15:30	01:15:30	General Case Activities
01:22:39	01:22:39	End of Session

August 3 - AM Session

Other

		Description
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:20	00:00:20	General Case Activities
00:12:16	00:12:16	Break
00:59:10	00:59:10	General Case Activities
00:59:48	00:59:48	General Case Activities
01:06:30	01:06:30	General Case Activities
01:09:30	01:09:30	End of Session

August 3 - PM Session

Other

		Description
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:01	00:00:01	General Case Activities
00:01:33	00:01:33	End of Session

August 2 - AM Session

Closings

		Description	Attorney
00:00:03	00:00:03	General Case Activities
00:00:13	00:00:13	General Case Activities
00:33:03	00:33:03	Closing Statement	Barnhart, Gregory
01:04:18	01:04:18	General Case Activities
01:05:28	01:05:28	Closing Statement	Barnhart, Gregory
02:12:43	02:12:43	General Case Activities
02:14:48	02:14:48	Break
02:35:09	02:35:09	Closing Statement	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn
02:45:41	02:45:41	Closing Statement
03:00:37	03:00:37	Closing Statement	Biersteker, Peter
05:02:53	05:02:53	End of Session

August 2 - PM Session

Not in Session

July 30 - AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:10	00:00:10	General Case Activities
00:02:00	00:02:00	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
00:15:15	00:15:15	Witness Cross Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
00:17:42	00:17:42	General Case Activities
00:19:44	00:19:44	General Case Activities		Piendle, Margaret	In Person
00:20:50	00:20:50	General Case Activities
00:23:32	00:23:32	General Case Activities
00:24:08	00:24:08	General Case Activities
00:25:05	00:25:05	General Case Activities	Scarola, Jack
00:34:05	00:34:05	General Case Activities
00:34:58	00:34:58	General Case Activities	Scarola, Jack
00:36:56	00:36:56	General Case Activities
00:37:26	00:37:26	General Case Activities	Scarola, Jack
00:39:50	00:39:50	General Case Activities
00:41:50	00:41:50	General Case Activities	Scarola, Jack
00:45:20	00:45:20	General Case Activities
00:45:55	00:45:55	General Case Activities
00:46:55	00:46:55	End of Session

July 30 - PM Session

Not in Session

July 29 - AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:20	00:00:20	General Case Activities
00:00:30	00:00:30	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
00:40:55	00:40:55	General Case Activities
00:41:30	00:41:30	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
00:45:50	00:45:50	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
01:15:58	01:15:58	General Case Activities
01:18:15	01:18:15	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
01:28:08	01:28:08	Break
01:45:40	01:45:40	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:00:05	02:00:05	General Case Activities
02:02:10	02:02:10	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:06:58	02:06:58	General Case Activities
02:08:22	02:08:22	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:29:10	02:29:10	General Case Activities
02:30:38	02:30:38	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:55:30	02:55:30	End of Session

July 29 - PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:01:19	00:01:19	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
01:21:15	01:21:15	Break
01:45:41	01:45:41	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:25:50	02:25:50	General Case Activities
02:26:50	02:26:50	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:29:57	02:29:57	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:47:40	02:47:40	General Case Activities
02:48:45	02:48:45	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:52:30	02:52:30	General Case Activities
02:56:48	02:56:48	General Case Activities
02:59:37	02:59:37	General Case Activities
03:03:26	03:03:26	End of Session

July 28 - AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:01	00:00:01	General Case Activities
00:02:15	00:02:15	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
00:31:05	00:31:05	General Case Activities
00:34:24	00:34:24	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
00:42:40	00:42:40	General Case Activities
00:45:40	00:45:40	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
01:23:05	01:23:05	Break
01:43:30	01:43:30	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
02:50:20	02:50:20	End of Session

July 28 - PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:10	00:00:10	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
00:32:35	00:32:35	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Farone, Dr. William Ph.D.	Video Recording
00:36:50	00:36:50	General Case Activities
00:46:05	00:46:05	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Farone, Dr. William Ph.D.	Transcript Reading
00:48:45	00:48:45	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Verely, Christi	Transcript Reading
00:52:57	00:52:57	General Case Activities
00:56:54	00:56:54	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Conizzio, Alan	Transcript Reading
01:06:02	01:06:02	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
01:31:00	01:31:00	Break
01:51:30	01:51:30	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
02:06:30	02:06:30	General Case Activities
02:10:08	02:10:08	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
03:10:10	03:10:10	General Case Activities
03:10:48	03:10:48	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Norell, Dr. Robert	In Person
03:13:25	03:13:25	End of Session

July 27 - AM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:10	00:00:10	General Case Activities
00:00:40	00:00:40	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:26:40	00:26:40	General Case Activities
00:29:42	00:29:42	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:56:30	00:56:30	General Case Activities
00:58:43	00:58:43	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
01:13:15	01:13:15	General Case Activities
01:17:58	01:17:58	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
01:24:15	01:24:15	Break
01:46:12	01:46:12	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
01:50:55	01:50:55	General Case Activities
01:53:21	01:53:21	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:07:18	02:07:18	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:26:20	02:26:20	General Case Activities
02:28:42	02:28:42	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:38:40	02:38:40	General Case Activities
02:40:15	02:40:15	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:51:40	02:51:40	General Case Activities
02:52:23	02:52:23	General Case Activities		Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:55:40	02:55:40	End of Session

July 27 - PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:20	00:00:20	General Case Activities
00:01:45	00:01:45	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
00:37:55	00:37:55	General Case Activities
00:38:45	00:38:45	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
00:48:54	00:48:54	General Case Activities
00:53:38	00:53:38	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
01:08:10	01:08:10	General Case Activities
01:09:20	01:09:20	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
01:15:11	01:15:11	General Case Activities	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
01:20:20	01:20:20	General Case Activities
01:22:02	01:22:02	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
01:25:23	01:25:23	Break
01:47:50	01:47:50	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
02:23:05	02:23:05	Witness Direct Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:25:25	02:25:25	Witness Cross Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:26:30	02:26:30	General Case Activities
02:28:16	02:28:16	Witness Cross Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:30:55	02:30:55	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
02:47:50	02:47:50	General Case Activities
02:51:05	02:51:05	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
03:01:00	03:01:00	General Case Activities
03:03:35	03:03:35	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
03:06:50	03:06:50	General Case Activities
03:07:42	03:07:42	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
03:10:50	03:10:50	General Case Activities
03:12:36	03:12:36	Witness Cross Examination	Sales, David	Riddel, Dr. Mary	In Person
03:20:50	03:20:50	End of Session

July 26 - AM Session

Other

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:30	00:00:30	General Case Activities
00:00:38	00:00:38	General Case Activities
00:02:35	00:02:35	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Verely, Christi	Transcript Reading
00:11:40	00:11:40	General Case Activities
00:12:52	00:12:52	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Verely, Christi	Transcript Reading
00:23:45	00:23:45	General Case Activities
00:25:09	00:25:09	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Verely, Christi	In Person
00:26:50	00:26:50	General Case Activities
00:29:12	00:29:12	General Case Activities
00:32:38	00:32:38	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:50:10	00:50:10	General Case Activities
00:51:35	00:51:35	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
01:33:25	01:33:25	Break
01:55:10	01:55:10	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:09:25	02:09:25	General Case Activities
02:12:35	02:12:35	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
03:01:45	03:01:45	End of Session

July 26 - PM Session

Defense Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:10	00:00:10	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:29:40	00:29:40	General Case Activities
00:31:24	00:31:24	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:33:45	00:33:45	General Case Activities
00:35:31	00:35:31	Witness Direct Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:40:50	00:40:50	Witness Direct Examination	Kelly, Frank	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:42:58	00:42:58	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
00:46:48	00:46:48	General Case Activities
00:50:05	00:50:05	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
01:38:28	01:38:28	Break
01:57:12	01:57:12	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:01:35	02:01:35	General Case Activities
02:02:25	02:02:25	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:41:15	02:41:15	General Case Activities
02:43:44	02:43:44	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
02:58:10	02:58:10	General Case Activities
02:59:55	02:59:55	Witness Cross Examination	Scarola, Jack	Figlar, Dr. James	In Person
03:05:18	03:05:18	End of Session

July 23 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:11	00:00:11	General Case Activities
00:00:31	00:00:31	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:35:46	00:35:46	General Case Activities
00:40:13	00:40:13	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:50:03	00:50:03	General Case Activities
00:52:16	00:52:16	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:59:22	00:59:22	General Case Activities
01:01:40	01:01:40	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:26:43	01:26:43	Break
01:51:59	01:51:59	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:36:43	02:36:43	End of Session

July 23 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:25	00:00:25	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:03:50	00:03:50	General Case Activities
00:05:05	00:05:05	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:24:55	01:24:55	Break
01:47:37	01:47:37	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:25:47	02:25:47	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:38:10	02:38:10	General Case Activities
02:41:34	02:41:34	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
03:21:29	03:21:29	General Case Activities
03:22:20	03:22:20	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
03:37:15	03:37:15	Break
03:40:50	03:40:50	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
03:50:00	03:50:00	General Case Activities
03:50:29	03:50:29	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
04:01:08	04:01:08	General Case Activities
04:02:47	04:02:47	General Case Activities		Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
04:04:58	04:04:58	General Case Activities
04:05:23	04:05:23	General Case Activities		Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
04:06:32	04:06:32	End of Session

July 22 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:18	00:00:18	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:35:25	01:35:25	Break
02:00:08	02:00:08	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:02:38	02:02:38	General Case Activities
02:05:21	02:05:21	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:53:51	02:53:51	End of Session

July 22 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:01	00:00:01	General Case Activities
00:00:10	00:00:10	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:17:47	00:17:47	General Case Activities
00:21:22	00:21:22	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:51:39	00:51:39	General Case Activities
00:53:41	00:53:41	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:22:30	01:22:30	General Case Activities
01:23:27	01:23:27	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:31:09	01:31:09	Break
02:01:44	02:01:44	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:12:22	02:12:22	General Case Activities
02:15:27	02:15:27	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:35:58	02:35:58	General Case Activities
02:39:32	02:39:32	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
03:15:47	03:15:47	General Case Activities
03:16:51	03:16:51	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
03:30:37	03:30:37	General Case Activities
03:31:47	03:31:47	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
03:37:52	03:37:52	End of Session

July 21 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:29	00:00:29	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
00:03:20	00:03:20	General Case Activities
00:06:35	00:06:35	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
00:15:04	00:15:04	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
00:44:16	00:44:16	General Case Activities
00:45:55	00:45:55	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
01:19:15	01:19:15	General Case Activities
01:20:53	01:20:53	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
01:26:20	01:26:20	General Case Activities
01:28:10	01:28:10	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
01:31:50	01:31:50	Break
01:53:50	01:53:50	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:08:20	02:08:20	General Case Activities
02:10:18	02:10:18	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:11:02	02:11:02	General Case Activities
02:12:15	02:12:15	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:12:40	02:12:40	General Case Activities
02:14:47	02:14:47	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:18:02	02:18:02	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:26:27	02:26:27	General Case Activities
02:29:20	02:29:20	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:35:40	02:35:40	General Case Activities
02:37:35	02:37:35	General Case Activities		Piendle, Margaret	In Person
02:39:45	02:39:45	End of Session

July 21 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:03	00:00:03	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
00:04:18	00:04:18	General Case Activities
00:08:18	00:08:18	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:16:03	01:16:03	Break
01:36:25	01:36:25	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:44:55	01:44:55	General Case Activities
01:48:18	01:48:18	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
01:59:01	01:59:01	General Case Activities
02:05:59	02:05:59	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:38:58	02:38:58	General Case Activities
02:43:59	02:43:59	Witness Direct Examination	Scarola, Jack	Cummings, Dr. Kenneth "Michael"	In Person
02:56:53	02:56:53	End of Session

July 20 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:10	00:00:10	General Case Activities
00:00:40	00:00:40	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
01:10:45	01:10:45	Break
01:26:55	01:26:55	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
01:46:35	01:46:35	Witness Cross Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
02:14:53	02:14:53	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
02:16:58	02:16:58	General Case Activities
02:20:40	02:20:40	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
02:34:20	02:34:20	General Case Activities
02:37:44	02:37:44	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
02:40:55	02:40:55	End of Session

July 20 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:06	00:00:06	General Case Activities
00:01:23	00:01:23	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Worobal, Lucille	In Person
00:22:11	00:22:11	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Worobal, Lucille	In Person
00:35:00	00:35:00	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Worobal, Lucille	In Person
00:40:26	00:40:26	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
00:59:26	00:59:26	General Case Activities
01:02:29	01:02:29	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
01:09:51	01:09:51	General Case Activities
01:12:33	01:12:33	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
01:20:34	01:20:34	Break
01:47:01	01:47:01	Witness Cross Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:01:31	02:01:31	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:06:31	02:06:31	General Case Activities
02:08:51	02:08:51	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:15:03	02:15:03	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Tracy	In Person
02:18:24	02:18:24	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Margaret	In Person
03:20:56	03:20:56	General Case Activities
03:22:41	03:22:41	General Case Activities		Piendle, Margaret	In Person
03:23:08	03:23:08	End of Session

July 19 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:30	00:00:30	General Case Activities
00:02:05	00:02:05	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Edward	In Person
00:13:18	00:13:18	General Case Activities
00:14:26	00:14:26	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Edward	In Person
00:38:35	00:38:35	General Case Activities
00:42:47	00:42:47	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Edward	In Person
00:47:40	00:47:40	General Case Activities
00:48:50	00:48:50	Witness Direct Examination	Baker-Barnes, Rosalyn	Piendle, Edward	In Person
00:56:40	00:56:40	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Piendle, Edward	In Person
01:21:15	01:21:15	Break
01:43:45	01:43:45	Witness Direct Examination	Briggs, Laurie	Cabral, Theodore	In Person
02:09:10	02:09:10	General Case Activities
02:09:28	02:09:28	Witness Cross Examination	Kessler, Elizabeth	Cabral, Theodore	In Person
02:30:52	02:30:52	Witness Cross Examination	Henk, Peter	Cabral, Theodore	In Person
02:35:38	02:35:38	General Case Activities
02:36:47	02:36:47	General Case Activities		Cabral, Theodore	In Person
02:38:05	02:38:05	General Case Activities
02:42:04	02:42:04	Witness Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
03:01:45	03:01:45	End of Session

July 19 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:14	00:00:14	Witness Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
00:28:37	00:28:37	General Case Activities
00:31:34	00:31:34	Witness Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
01:22:30	01:22:30	Break
01:41:22	01:41:22	Witness Direct Examination	Barnhart, Gregory	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
02:33:40	02:33:40	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
02:39:45	02:39:45	General Case Activities
02:42:44	02:42:44	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Benowitz, Dr. Neal	In Person
03:08:50	03:08:50	End of Session

July 16 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:05	00:00:05	General Case Activities
00:00:28	00:00:28	General Case Activities
00:01:05	00:01:05	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
01:23:30	01:23:30	Break
01:44:30	01:44:30	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
02:47:45	02:47:45	End of Session

July 16 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:01	00:00:01	General Case Activities
00:00:21	00:00:21	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
00:27:36	00:27:36	General Case Activities
00:29:31	00:29:31	Witness Cross Examination	Biersteker, Peter	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
00:46:03	00:46:03	General Case Activities
00:50:16	00:50:16	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
01:43:41	01:43:41	Break
02:06:34	02:06:34	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
02:38:34	02:38:34	General Case Activities
02:42:36	02:42:36	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
02:58:31	02:58:31	General Case Activities
03:04:34	03:04:34	Witness Cross Examination	Kelly, Frank	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
03:08:51	03:08:51	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
03:34:11	03:34:11	General Case Activities
03:35:31	03:35:31	Witness Re-Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
03:39:16	03:39:16	General Case Activities
03:43:04	03:43:04	General Case Activities
03:44:31	03:44:31	End of Session

July 15 - AM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:15	00:00:15	General Case Activities
00:01:50	00:01:50	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
01:19:12	01:19:12	General Case Activities
01:20:26	01:20:26	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
01:27:20	01:27:20	Break
01:49:27	01:49:27	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
02:15:57	02:15:57	General Case Activities
02:16:55	02:16:55	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
02:48:35	02:48:35	General Case Activities
02:52:15	02:52:15	General Case Activities
02:52:45	02:52:45	End of Session

July 15 - PM Session

Plaintiff Witness(es)

		Description	Attorney	Witness	Presence
00:00:03	00:00:03	General Case Activities
00:00:13	00:00:13	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
01:17:20	01:17:20	General Case Activities
01:19:08	01:19:08	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
01:22:08	01:22:08	Break
01:43:55	01:43:55	General Case Activities
01:45:33	01:45:33	Witness Direct Examination	Sales, David	Burns, Dr. David MD	In Person
03:02:53	03:02:53	End of Session

July 14 - AM Session

Openings

		Description	Attorney
00:00:05	00:00:05	General Case Activities
00:00:18	00:00:18	Opening Statement	Barnhart, Gregory
02:00:10	02:00:10	End of Session

July 14 - PM Session

Openings

		Description	Attorney
00:00:00	00:00:00	General Case Activities
00:00:10	00:00:10	Opening Statement	Biersteker, Peter
00:19:55	00:19:55	General Case Activities
00:21:00	00:21:00	Opening Statement	Biersteker, Peter
01:14:05	01:14:05	Break
01:39:00	01:39:00	Opening Statement	Kelly, Frank
02:34:58	02:34:58	General Case Activities
02:37:05	02:37:05	End of Session