Boca Aviation v. Proskauer Rose

Trial   05/06/10 – 06/11/10

Case Number
2006-CA-002732
Status
Concluded - Mistrial
Industry
Legal, Aviation
Practice Area
Malpractice, Real Property, Government Contracts
Judge
David Crow
Court
Palm Beach County Courthouse
Jurisdiction
15th Judicial Circuit of Florida

Description

4-week legal malpractice jury trial.

Boca Aviation was a fixed base operator at Boca Raton Airport. Boca Aviation had a long-term lease on 45 acres, and was the sole provider of aviation services, including fuel, at Boca Airport.

When additional airport land became available, Proskauer executed lease amendments that attempted to secure Boca Aviation's position as sole fuel provider at the airport, but the local airport authority eventually brought in a competing fixed base operator.

Boca Aviation claimed that it had won the right to develop the remaining airport land itself, which would have secured its position as sole fuel provider, but that it lost its right due to Proskauer's handling of the lease amendments.

Proskauer asserted that Boca Aviation did not have a legal right to exclude a competing fuel provider, and therefore Proskauer was not responsible for the eventual loss of Boca's exclusivity.

For more about the case, visit the CVN Blog.

View a free video clip from the case:
Plaintiff's Opening Statement -- Clip 1

Sessions
Recording Disclaimer: This proceeding was recorded in full.

June 8 - AM Session
Not in Session
June 8 - PM Session
Not in Session
June 7 - PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
Description Attorney Witness Presence
00:00:15 General Case Activities
00:00:34 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
00:13:20 General Case Activities
00:17:00 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
00:25:45 General Case Activities
00:26:10 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
00:27:55 General Case Activities
00:28:47 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
00:36:25 General Case Activities
00:37:05 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
00:52:35 General Case Activities
01:00:40 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
01:35:20 General Case Activities
01:36:50 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
02:05:20 Break
02:21:55 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
02:23:00 General Case Activities
02:23:24 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Rickerson, David In Person
02:39:38 Witness Re-Direct Examination Heise, Mark Rickerson, David In Person
02:45:30 General Case Activities
02:45:56 Witness Re-Direct Examination Heise, Mark Rickerson, David In Person
02:54:45 General Case Activities
03:27:50 General Case Activities
03:30:40 Witness Direct Examination Scarola, Jack Wheeler, Christopher Video Recording
04:06:20 End of Session
June 4 - AM Session
Not in Session
June 4 - PM Session
Not in Session
June 3 - PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
Description Attorney Witness Presence
00:00:00 General Case Activities
00:00:12 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Quinn, Kenneth In Person
00:30:32 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Quinn, Kenneth In Person
00:38:00 General Case Activities
00:54:50 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Quinn, Kenneth In Person
00:55:25 General Case Activities
00:56:15 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Quinn, Kenneth In Person
01:00:21 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
01:24:00 General Case Activities
01:24:49 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
01:29:10 General Case Activities
01:30:29 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
01:43:20 General Case Activities
01:44:30 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
01:45:20 Break
02:05:58 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
02:21:05 General Case Activities
02:22:20 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
02:26:40 General Case Activities
02:28:32 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
02:52:28 General Case Activities
02:54:42 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
03:04:10 General Case Activities
03:05:42 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
03:40:20 General Case Activities
03:40:52 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
03:43:32 General Case Activities
03:45:03 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
03:55:53 Witness Re-Direct Examination Scarola, Jack Quinn, Kenneth In Person
03:58:30 End of Session
June 2 - PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
Description Attorney Witness Presence
00:00:00 General Case Activities
00:00:09 Witness Direct Examination Molar, Barry In Person
00:05:12 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Molar, Barry Video Recording
00:20:15 General Case Activities
00:22:10 Witness Cross Examination Rubinstein, Craig Molar, Barry Video Recording
00:53:15 Break
01:28:40 Witness Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
01:36:30 General Case Activities
01:37:20 Witness Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
01:39:58 General Case Activities
01:40:33 Witness Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
01:45:32 General Case Activities
01:46:17 Witness Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
02:02:20 General Case Activities
02:14:34 Witness Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
02:18:15 Witness Cross Examination Katzman, Steven Sherr, Janet In Person
02:26:53 General Case Activities
02:27:17 Witness Cross Examination Katzman, Steven Sherr, Janet In Person
02:35:32 General Case Activities
02:35:57 Witness Cross Examination Katzman, Steven Sherr, Janet In Person
02:40:18 Witness Re-Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
02:41:55 General Case Activities
02:43:00 Witness Re-Direct Examination Melville, Patricia Sherr, Janet In Person
02:44:30 Witness Direct Examination Pitts, James Video Recording
02:52:40 General Case Activities
03:02:50 Witness Direct Examination Pitts, James Video Recording
03:46:20 End of Session
June 1 - PM Session
Defense Witness(es)
Description Attorney Witness Presence
00:00:09 General Case Activities
00:00:38 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Walker, William In Person
00:16:04 General Case Activities
00:16:53 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Walker, William In Person
00:31:09 General Case Activities
00:32:29 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Walker, William In Person
01:22:19 General Case Activities
01:24:33 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Walker, William In Person
01:29:04 General Case Activities
01:29:59 Witness Cross Examination Scarola, Jack Walker, William In Person
01:33:09 Witness Re-Direct Examination Heise, Mark Walker, William In Person
01:46:44 Break
02:06:34 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Sieck, Charles In Person
02:30:39 General Case Activities
02:31:24 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Sieck, Charles In Person
02:39:49 General Case Activities
02:40:36 Witness Direct Examination Heise, Mark Sieck, Charles In Person
02:41:23 Witness Cross Examination Katzman, Steven Sieck, Charles In Person
02:44:49 General Case Activities
02:45:21 Witness Cross Examination Katzman, Steven Sieck, Charles In Person
03:06:39 General Case Activities
03:07:09 Witness Cross Examination Katzman, Steven Sieck, Charles In Person
03:14:29 Witness Re-Direct Examination Heise, Mark Sieck, Charles In Person
03:22:29 General Case Activities
03:26:29 Witness Direct Examination Molar, Barry Video Recording
03:41:21 End of Session
May 31 - AM Session
Not in Session
May 31 - PM Session
Not in Session
May 28 - AM Session
Not in Session
May 28 - PM Session
Not in Session
May 27 - AM Session
Not in Session
May 27 - PM Session
Not in Session
May 26 - AM Session
Not in Session
May 26 - PM Session
Not in Session
May 24 - PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
May 19 - PM Session
Not in Session
May 18 - PM Session
Plaintiff Witness(es)
Description Attorney Witness Presence
00:00:30 General Case Activities
00:01:30 Witness Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Berger, C. In Person
00:16:15 Witness Cross Examination Melville, Patricia Berger, C. In Person
00:30:25 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Berger, C. In Person
00:32:15 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Wantshouse, Mark In Person
00:43:55 General Case Activities
00:44:30 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Wantshouse, Mark In Person
00:46:25 General Case Activities
00:48:38 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Wantshouse, Mark In Person
00:49:35 General Case Activities
00:50:30 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Wantshouse, Mark In Person
01:00:00 General Case Activities
01:01:50 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Wantshouse, Mark In Person
01:28:00 General Case Activities
01:29:40 Witness Re-Direct Examination Katzman, Steven Wantshouse, Mark In Person
01:32:10 Break
01:47:35 Witness Direct Examination Scarola, Jack Greenberg, Martin In Person
02:40:45 General Case Activities
02:41:30 Witness Direct Examination Scarola, Jack Greenberg, Martin In Person
03:01:25 General Case Activities
03:02:22 Witness Direct Examination Scarola, Jack Greenberg, Martin In Person
03:13:40 General Case Activities
03:14:22 Witness Direct Examination Scarola, Jack Greenberg, Martin In Person
03:23:05 End of Session
May 14 - AM Session
Not in Session
May 14 - PM Session
Not in Session
May 7 - AM Session
Not in Session
May 7 - PM Session
Not in Session